The Government's Job Report—and Ours
The Latest Unemployment Report from the National Jobs for All Network
The Latest Unemployment Report from the National Jobs for All Network
Some of the numbers in the Bureau of Labor Statistics employment report were pretty good. You will see in NJFAN’s Full Count that the overall official unemployment rate for October was just 4.1%. That’s pretty low. But there’s a different story and a warning about deep problems in other data. The unemployment rate for African Americans was 6.6% and for Black teens it was an unbelievable 23.3%. Also, NJFAN experts estimate a more realistic level of unemployment that includes some people who want a job but have not looked recently, and part-timers who want full-time work. That total unemployment rate was 10.1% in October and it was up from the September rate of 9.9%.
There are many other factors than unemployment affecting the situation of millions of Americans. Growth in the real Gross Domestic Product—total output—was good in the third quarter—the months of July, August, and September. Much of that growth was fueled by AI investments and consumer spending. But consumers pulled back toward the end of the quarter. Quite a few had already dug deeply into their savings to pay for necessities, and some were now beginning to pull back from that strategy. Also, while it is clear that AI growth continues at a very high level, it does not put much money into the pockets of average consumers. It will never be a net job creator.
Without significant increases in real pay and easier credit, total consumption and economic growth may slow. Inflation is eating away at average incomes, and things could get worse soon. Wholesale prices, which tend to be a predictor of consumer prices, increased 6.5% over the last twelve months. That’s very high and it is bad for two reasons. One seems obvious. All other things being equal, those higher prices will work their way out to consumers, and consumers are already having trouble affording stuff. Prices have risen about 4% over the past year. But also, higher prices incentivize the Federal Reserve Board to do risky things, and, in particular, to raise interest rates to slow economic demand and price increases. That could create a recession. That little thing normally throws hundreds of thousands of people out of work.
And raising interest rates seems a paradoxical way to cut inflation; it can add directly to the inflation rate. Businesses and consumers are directly affected by interest rates. As Robert Kuttner at The American Prospect recently pointed out, interest rates are part of the cost of living for many people. And currently, interest rates are pretty high, due to a combination of things. Large Federal deficits mean heavy Federal demand for money and that pushes interest rates up. Also, spending on the war against Iran adds to the deficit. (Not to mention the direct effect of the war on petroleum prices.)
Meanwhile, deficits caused by massive tax cuts favoring the rich also cause heavy federal borrowing and that can push up some interest rates. And there are other heavy demands on credit markets, including massive AI borrowing. One result of all these inflationary pressures is rather shocking. Kuttner writes that average interest rates for 30-year mortgages have increased from 3% in 2020-21 to almost 7% in 2026!
Inflation cuts into apparent increases in wages. As this column has often noted, real wages have not increased much in recent years. And the last year was no exception. For the BLS category of all employees, in eight of the last eleven months, real pay fell or did not budge. In only three months did real hourly wages increase.
We at NJFAN want a government Good Jobs for All Program to create not just more jobs, but good jobs. We also want to lift existing jobs. For me, it is an abomination that the federal minimum wage is $7.25. That amount is sub-sub minimum. Few workers actually earn that, but such a low Federal minimum shows contempt for low-wage workers. Is ours a third world country? In this area the answer is yes.
A progressive and humane reform might be something like a Two-over-Ten program: raise the minimum wage $2 a year for ten years. In 2037, the federal minimum wage would be $27.75. Too horrible to contemplate? Is $55,000 for a full year’s work by an average worker just too scary to think about? And do the working poor need all that money? Well, we all know that even today that is not so much, especially if one is supporting a family. And remember, too, in 2037, after ten years of inflation, the constant value of that $55,000 would be about $39,000 in today’s purchasing power. Surely that is below what a reasonable poverty line should be in America.
What about lost jobs because workers get too expensive? There will be losses and some businesses will go kerplooie. If we want a rational and moral society, we should tax the rich and the affluent more in order to fund millions of new good jobs. It does not take a Ph.D. in economics or ethics to figure out that there are dozens of areas that need more workers. Head Start, other child-care services, low-income housing, health care in underserved areas, and thousands of jobs in a dozen Federal departments raided by DOGE. You can name other areas.
Which is more horrible to contemplate? Once-poor people earning a living wage of $55,000 a year, or a billionaire who destroyed thousands of vital federal jobs, spent $500,000,000 to sway voters in the state of Texas, and battled to defeat a one-time 5% state tax on the incomes of the very, very rich?